Touch


Several years ago, I noticed a lump in my neck; I was no longer young, and I was terrified. The differential diagnosis was given to me by a colleague I greatly respected, but I had not expected the presentation to be so matter of fact. I don’t know what I had anticipated, but somehow there was a gap between her words and my condition, between her and me, I suppose. That something so important to me could be offered as mere words seemed inadequate. Incomplete. When I looked into her eyes hoping I had misheard, I could see the compassion and the empathy, but it was more like reading a story in a book: the information was there, the meaning clear, but it required an effort on my part to extract it. The story, in other words, was incomplete.

And then she did something that I will always remember -something that for me, proved I had gone to the right doctor: she reached across and touched the hand I had placed on her desk to steady myself. That little gesture of reassurance, that small reminder of the link we all share was enough to see me through that day. And it taught me something about medicine -no, about humanity. About Life.

Words are sometimes simply not enough; explanations, however thorough, are often incomplete.

There’s something magical about touch. I saw a patient in the office on whom I had recently operated. After asking her the usual questions about how she was feeling now that her much-anticipated and dreaded surgery was over, she settled back in her chair with a smile.

“You know, doctor,” she said, placing her hands on my desk for emphasis, “Everybody was so nice in the hospital… I never imagined it would be like that.”

I smiled in return, thinking she would comment on how thoroughly we had discussed the procedure the day after surgery, or the care we had taken to alleviate her pain… Maybe the smiles we had brought to her on our twice-daily rounds… Our constant reassurance, our patience in answering her questions… Our willingness to listen to her. “A hospital can be a frightening place, can’t it?” I said, more as a statement than a question.

She nodded. “Especially at night when all the visitors and doctors have left. It’s a time when you’re all alone in the darkness and those scary thoughts of cancer and bleeding and infection come swirling around like bees to a hive. I remember lying there, staring at the ceiling and worrying. I was wide awake despite the pain medications and a nurse came in to see how I was doing. She was young -about my granddaughter’s age maybe; I hadn’t seen her before. I guess she thought I would be asleep, but when she noticed my eyes were open, she came over to the bed. And you know the first thing she did?”

I could see a tear beginning to form in one of her eyes, so I leaned forward to show her I was listening.

“She took my hand and held it. And you know, for the first time in there, I realized I wasn’t alone. Somebody, a stranger, noticed that I was afraid and came over to comfort me. She didn’t say anything; she didn’t have to…”

There is a dark corridor we all must walk; touch is often inappropriate, damaging. And yet it can be therapeutic, a bridge between the empty, cold empire of words and the warm land of feeling, understanding and empathy. It is an opportunity for communication that can not be taught, only felt -the word itself a testament to its importance. No, I’m not advocating a radical new approach to medicine, an ill-advised crossing of the line. And I’m not so naive as to believe that it is always necessary as proof that a concern has registered. But a hand briefly resting on a shoulder on the way out of the door is sometimes okay, don’t you think?

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s